Skip to main content


Apparently Reddit has now banned a subreddit dedicated to the Fediverse Reddit-alternative Kbin:

https://sakurajima.moe/@chikorita157/110517156242412322

If you're on a centralised platform like Reddit, this is what they can do. Centralised platforms have all-powerful leaders who can do whatever they want, and you have no alternatives if you disagree.

The point of the Fediverse being on lots of servers is that each server's power is limited. If you disagree with one server's actions, you can move.

#Fediverse #Reddit #Kbin

Thanks for making me aware of Kbin :PinkHeart: I was only previously aware of Lemmy, which (as you've covered yourself) is not really a viable option.
@SleepyCatten why is kbin more viable than lemmy? i checked kbim just now and at first glance it's both slower and has a less polished interface.

Content warning: Lemmy

Content warning: Lemmy

Content warning: Lemmy

Content warning: Lemmy

@SleepyCatten kbin is so much better than lemmy in the ui side.

I'm having a heck of time rolling an instance tho since their documentation is a travesty!

@wagesof @SleepyCatten

Yeah, the developer said today they're currently working on the documentation for making an instance, as they're aware we need more of them right now.

This entry was edited (1 year ago)
@wagesof @SleepyCatten
More instances and a mobile app and it would probably get a lot more people willing to try it

@JuLe @SleepyCatten @RassilonianLegate @wagesof

The project is tiny and new, it needs support to achieve all these things.

If you are a programmer you can help at https://codeberg.org/Kbin/kbin-core

If you are not a programmer, you can donate at https://www.buymeacoffee.com/kbin

I don’t think fediverse is going to enter the general vocabulary.

Ian Molton doesn't like this.

@TheDude

I think it could? Email and the web are open standards in general vocab, and they aren't corporate brand names.

@TheDude I mean, it has the word "Fed" in it. May leave a rotten taste in many a soul's mouth.
Yeah, All those Star Trek nerds must HATE it...
since yesterday I didn't even know that such alternative exists. Seems reddit doesn't know about Streisand effect :fatpikachu:
well, I signed up to kbin now, seems cool
what an admirable bastion of free speech

This is a long read, but it very succinctly explains why these things inevitably always will happen on centralized systems:

https://www.wired.com/story/tiktok-platforms-cory-doctorow/

@Kathrin

Yes! People who enjoy the article should follow the author at @pluralistic

There was a time when TikTok *wasnt* shit?
@spyro
I know you're being facetious but TikTok likely appeals to a different demographic and within that audience, it was great - for a time.
I understand some people liked the format. But TikTok as a *platform* was an Obvious Plant from day one...
@spyro
If you're referring to the data harvesting (aka spying), then sure. However, that applies to pretty much any other platform as well.
It has its place 😝
they're absolutely shameless
They really are Twittering this

@Lazycog
Add to that that this content follows the old 90% lurker, 9% interacter and 1% creator rule of thumb.

I would not be surprised if the Venn diagram between creators and people who use 3rd party apps approaches a circle.

@aleklu @Lazycog

Also, the long form posts on Reddit mean it's a lot more dependent on creators.

There are sometimes really good deep dive posts on Reddit in a way that have never existed on Twitter, due to the different posting format.

reminds me of twitter trying to suppress mastodon migration

#RedditCensorship takes #Elmo's #BorgSite approach and eliminated #Fediverse entry.

https://mstdn.social/@feditips/110519237586930084

Act now to protect your content and use the #Fediverse's #FOSS alternatives:

#Lemmy or #Kbin:

https://mastodon.social/@HistoPol/110516948024413608

#JoinTheFediverse.net
#jointhefediverse


Apparently Reddit has now banned a subreddit dedicated to the Fediverse Reddit-alternative Kbin:

https://sakurajima.moe/@chikorita157/110517156242412322

If you're on a centralised platform like Reddit, this is what they can do. Centralised platforms have all-powerful leaders who can do whatever they want, and you have no alternatives if you disagree.

The point of the Fediverse being on lots of servers is that each server's power is limited. If you disagree with one server's actions, you can move.

#Fediverse #Reddit #Kbin


It is in the design, centralised platforms should be discouraged. Its just not safe when going beyond a certain size and also not democratic. Substandard hence. Rules and regulations can help here, given the potential high impact we have seen with these platforms on society…
I call it Twitterfication.

guess they really are fearful of people moving off Reddit after all.
Surely they should support a free and open internet...

The idea of people hating and leaving Reddit terrifies them. If Reddit was such a great platform they shouldn't have anything to worry about. Yet years of never delivering on promises has finally and justly come back to haunt them.

LOL, Reddit going full Twitter.

@doug @mauveavenger @TheDude

Yeah, federation is a neutral word in most of the world. It just means an organisation of independent groups.

sorry for a really dumb question on Kban…how do I sign up with my mastodon user name? What’s the proper format? I keep getting a “match format” message. I’m not sure why I’m struggling with. Mastodon was a breeze compared to this. 😔

@SocialSpirit

If you want to sign up on another server, you need to create an account on that server.

Your Mastodon account is tied to the Mastodon server where you signed up, you can't use it to sign in on any other server.

It's like with email, you can't use your Gmail account to sign in on Yahoo Mail, even though you can send emails between Gmail and Yahoo Mail accounts.

ok, I think I understand that, but when I look at users on kban it displays their other instance info as well (eg: FEDITIPS @feditips@mastodon.social). I’ve just created a kban account displaying USERNAME @username@kban.social which isn’t what I want. Does that make sense or am I totally missing something. Thanks for your patience, I don’t know why I don’t get this.

@SocialSpirit

The users you can see with other instance info are on other instances. They may not be on Kban at all, or they might be on different Kban servers.

The idea of the Fediverse is people are spread out on thousands of different servers, but the servers communicate seamlessly so that people from many different servers can have conversations together.

You and I are on different servers but we are able to talk like this, because the servers we signed up on communicate with each other.

@SocialSpirit the bit that's always stumped me is why I've got to have one profile per fedi app rather than a single unified profile.

@cooopsspace @SocialSpirit

You don't need an account on every service.

One account will usually let you interact on other services. From your point of view it will look like you're just on Mastodon, but you're actually on other services too.

For example, if you want to comment on a PeerTube video, you can do that from Mastodon. From your point of view it will look like a Mastodon thread, but when you go to the PeerTube video's own page the comment you made on Mastodon will be there.

For example if you go to @theatticdwellers you'll see PeerTube posts, even though they look like Mastodon posts from your point of view. If you like them on Mastodon, it will appear as a thumbs up on PeerTube. If you reply to one of those videos, it will appear as a comment on PeerTube.
This entry was edited (1 year ago)
@SocialSpirit but if I have a @pixelfed account because I prefer an Instagram like interface - I suddenly can't see text posts at all. So if I want text posting and to be able to upload photos... But I also want pixelfed to be my app of choice there is currently no way to do that without multiple accounts with no way of unifying them under one persona.
Got a quick primer for how to use Kbin somewhere? It says it will automatically make magazines or whatnot based on interest, but does that mean I sign myself up to be a moderator?

that's hilarious, imagine being so scared that you start barring the doors and blocking people from leaving.

Reddit death spiral, and I'm here for it.

I'm putting a lot of my energy into setting up a kbin backup for my favorite subreddits so their moderators have less work to do if they choose to migrate the community.
Of COURSE this was going to happen! OF COURSE!
I can confirm that the mods in the Discord organising the Reddit protest are discussing alternatives. The problem is that the value in a social network comes from scale. Reddit was great because on any topic you could guarantee a strong community. Add "Reddit" to any Google Search and you'd be guaranteed a good result. It's going to be very hard to replicate that benefit in the fediverse, even if I hope it can happen.
I've only heard of Lemmy so far. Are there any real differences between Lemmy and Kbin?
What's the difference between #kbin and #lemmy?
@Zudn From what I can tell, very little from a functional standpoint. Lemmy reportedly has a core dev who's raised some controversy, though I'm not privy to the details.
@Zudn
I'm neither shocked nor surprised that reddit banned discussions of kbin. It's interesting because in doing so, they've made a tacit admission that it is a threat to their business model.

What #kbin instances are there out there?

Kbin dot social is super full rn, and using the main instance isn’t usually good anyway

(Also, any kbin apps for iOS?)

#kbin

@luana Karab.in is the only other english one I know of. There are a handful of polish instances (AFAIK the kbin dev is polish).

But if you have the knowledge and resources you should totally host your own kbin instance!

@Bees karab.in seems to be polish too?

Also nah, I don’t even self-host my mastodon account lmaoo

@luana @Bees

The admin of Kbin posted today that they're giving priority to documenting how to set up Kbin servers, to speed up the process of more servers being set up.

Corporations truly are the enemies of freedom.
Wasn't there some reddit api thingy that is going to close because of cost? Can't they also use this free replacement? If we had a search that was general I could connect them up in a few seconds, but I know it is lost way too far in my TL to ever find ☹️
@TransitBiker Private equity never met a business it couldn’t ruin.
@doug @mauveavenger @TheDude federation is a great concept and has only a positive meaning in my part of the world.

Thanks. Now I know about bin as well. Having heard questionable things about Lemmy (don't ask me what, I already forgot ;-), I'm keen to learn about alternatives.

They banned the group, but the topic lives on. Here's one useful thread that came from searching reddit for "kbin"

https://www.reddit.com/r/RedditAlternatives/comments/140bxax/kbinsocial_is_an_easy_to_onboard_lemmy/

Content warning: Lemmy

Content warning: Lemmy

Content warning: Lemmy, human rights abuses

Content warning: Lemmy

Content warning: Lemmy

I wanted to say, colour me surprised... but then again, it is discount Elon Musk we are dealing here with.
Tyrants going to tyrant! Glad we dipping! 🚀

Content warning: Lemmy

p.s. Have had lot of people asking similar questions, so here are some answers:

Kbin's website is at https://kbin.pub, they have a flagship server at https://kbin.social. There's no app yet, but you can use Kbin servers through their websites.

The lead developer of Kbin is @ernest, at the moment that's the account to follow for news on the project.

If you want to help Kbin there's a donation link at https://www.buymeacoffee.com/kbin, and programmers can help at https://codeberg.org/Kbin

This entry was edited (1 year ago)
@ernest Note, however, that the flagship instance uses cloudflare, very bad for privacy.
@Stemy Can you recommend a better DNS provider?
The thing that gets to me about Cloudflare is not the big picture on privacy with their services, it's the appalling decision to share details of complainants with hate sites (which I'd forgotten about until I saw your post). Of course if they did that it throws everything else about them into question.
@alastair87 @alastair87 @ernest wow!! I never knew that!! that is hidious! moved my domains to them due to them being an at cost registrar, might look again for someone else who also interfaces with my yunohost instance ie can push records to the registrar automatically.
why not set up bind and run your own DNS - I've recently done that and wont be looking back... feel free to PM me
@spyro @alastair87 @ernest ah is that like a dns server? this is more for domains, ie A AAA cname records etc.

bind is a DNS server, yes.

Now, rather than managing DNS on some crappy web interfaces, I can just edit the zone files on my primary DNS server, and it "just works".

All I had to do with my domain registrar is replace the DNS record info they held before (which is now on my servers) and enter my three nameservers into their interface. Job done.

@spyro @spyro @alastair87 @ernest wow!! impressive. although I prefer a web interface, to be fair. also, yunohost which I use on my cloud server, links up with cloudflares API, so say when I create, example.gm-cloud.org.uk it will automatically push the dns records for that to cloudflare with one click. not that this forgives cloudflare for their hidious policy of giving info to hate sites.

Sure, but my VPSes are *minute*. Up until yesterday I had Debian bookworm running a Mailserver on just 5GiB of disk.

(I've added more disk now as its handling a lot more stuff now.)

Apart from pushing DNS with one click (not that you need to do that anyway, if you run your own), why do you want a web interface to configure the machine - its just one more vulnerability.

@spyro @spyro @alastair87 @ernest well, i have no linux or command line knowledge, or very little!

That's fair.

Feel free to ask. I'm happy to share the info I have.

@spyro @spyro @alastair87 @ernest awww. thank you, really appreciate it. will do if I ever run into an issue, though for day to day stuff I like an easy life haha!

I actually switched from the DNS providers web interfaces (123 and fasthosts) to doing it "properly" precisely because it was much easier to ssh in and edit a zone file on my primary DNS and run 'rndc reload', rather than to go to their site (after working out if the domain was 123 or fasthosts reg), then logging in, 2FA, navigate past the ads, find where they moved stuff to (looking at you, 123), and finally edit. the. records. one. at. a. time. via their crappy web interface.

I can update DNS for any/all of my half a dozen domains in about 30 seconds, rather than several minutes. I can even schedule the changes with cron if I want to.

@spyro @spyro @alastair87 @ernest wow!! i think its a bit different for me being blind I use a screen reader, not figured out how to edit a file in ssh, what I have to do is, ftp into my server, download file, edit, upload again. which actually sounds quicker than all the steps you've just outlined! for its apparent hidious faults, cloudflares api works pretty well in conjunction with yunohost.

I dont have direct experience of using a screen reader, but it seems to me that the command line might be easier to use in this regard?

to edit (say) a zone file on my server, I can do:

ssh me@my.server.com
vim /etc/bind/zones/db.my.zone
rndc reload

alternatively, if I have a local copy, I could edit that and upload it directly into place with:

scp local_copy me@my.server.com:/etc/bind/zones/
ssh me@my.server.com rndc reload

@spyro @spyro @alastair87 @ernest oh command line is pretty accessible, to be fair. its just when putty loads file its hard to know how to deal with it, and i dont want to end up doing the wrong thing, editing it or thinking ive edited it right, and mucking it up. its also remembering the commands, putty is very difficult to paste from windows clipboard, to putty, for instance, ctrl V doesnt work,

@stemy @ernest Not normally. That was temporally implemented a few hours back to mitigate what looked like a DDoS.

In retrospect it may have just been the HN/Digg/Slashdot/Reddit effect but until that eases of it is making the site usable.

@pieceofthepie @stemy @ernest

Yeah, can confirm they didn't have Cloudflare earlier in the day.

2023 is the year of the fediverse or at least i hope.

@plaws(N5UWY/VE2UWY-he/him)🇨🇦🇺🇸 Yes, but the difference is that you don't have to sign up with that instance to engage with its users. Likewise, you can migrate to another instance if you disagree with the policies of your current one.

It's not a bulletproof system, but it's far more resistant to that kind of nonsense.

Edit: typo

This entry was edited (1 year ago)
That instance can however just refuse to federate with others and if it gets to critical mass it will be difficult to escape. In a sense that's not too dissimilar to how Big Tech social media operates now by restricting interoperability and limiting what you can do with the APIs.

"AFAIK (and may be wrong!) there is no prohibition against for-profit Mastodon instances."

It's not about the ownership, it's about the structure of the network. As long as we're spread out on many servers, if a single sever misbehaves, all their users could simply migrate to another server.

On here, you can migrate while keeping your follows and followers.

On centralised networks like Reddit/Twitter/Facebook you would lose all your follows/followers.

This entry was edited (1 year ago)

Sounds like a good idea, until your server is targeted by defederation from multiple popular and well used servers

#Fediverse #Reddit #Kbin

It's back on Reddit again now. I agree with the fundamental critique of centralised social media but I'm not sure anything sinister happened here.
Deleted my 10+ year profile today. Reddit was my doom scrolling platform. So much to sift through for the good stuff.
I started trying out Kbin yesterday. I'm liking what I'm seeing so far, I'm just hoping more instances get set up soon. I'm on kbin.social and it's struggling due to all the new users. I'm pretty techy but not quite enough to set up my own instance unfortunately. Do you know if it's easy to switch instances on kbin like you can on mastodon? Or do you have to set up a new account if you want to switch kbin instances?

@theprincessofcute

It's still really, really new, as far as I know they haven't added direct account transfers yet.

well hopefully that's coming. Doesn't matter too much right now since there's only a couple of instances anyways
The Kbin one and various other fediverse subreddits are literally still there!!
It was apparently re-instated. Similar is supposed to have happened with Lemmy...
I should be clear I'm not trusting or even defending Reddit, I just don't like the pattern I see here of something being so readily accepted without a lot of scrutiny by the people replying. It repeats a really bad aspect of mainstream social media.
Lemmy is the better option. I've been using it for a bit and it's way more engaged. And because it's the fediverse, if you aren't so sure about the content of an instance, there are a couple others to choose from. I'm also sure there are moderation issues with the influx of new users. I haven't seen any outwardly offensive/anti human rights content at all.

The thing with social networks is that they're unlike any other product or service. People use it to communicate and organize, and form communities inside it.

So censoring people because they're openly plotting to replace a service with a different one shouldn't be considered "breach of contract" or "playing dirty", or whatever the CEO thinks. Because they are a community.

It should be illegal to censor people for discussing alternative platforms or social networks.

Making a social network for-profit is literally buying the town square. Abusing that power is a despicable thing to do.

I think the obvious equivalent is pubs/bars/theatres etc. The difference is though that they don't generally monopolise the space like the big social media firms.

Each subreddit is a fiefdom dictatorship so this behavior should come naturally to them.

Though they’ll find it’s easier to dish out tyranny than it is to undergo it. #Reddit

Content warning: Lemmy

I think collectively, internet users have fallen into the trap that a service has to exist to use it, and that they then must choose from the "bestest" service providers or make do with nothing.

I dont know how this narrative came to be the "received wisdom", but its simply not true.

With a small VPS you can run nearly anything yourself. Need DNS? bind. mail? exim, postfix, dovecot, sendmail... Social media? friendica, masto, diaspora... maps.

The whole *point* of DNS was to distribute the task - not make it something you leave to a handful of giants.

Grr.

99% of the population do not have the technical knowledge nor the time to maintain their own infrastructure like that. There should be many more smaller options, but your expectation sometime seems akin to expecting people to forego car mechanics or seeing their GP and do it all themselves whilst still having time for the rest of their lives. Fine in this case if it's a special interest, not so much if not and especially not for the people who have no technical aptitude.

I say that as someone who self-hosts several of my services on a VPS (private DNS resolver, cloud storage, code repositories in gitea, personal web site) and other fully private ones on a server in my own home where I have several terabytes of HDD storage connected.

This entry was edited (1 year ago)

I have found Cloudflare excellent from a technical perspective.

However from an ethical point of view there have been serious issues with them failing to limit access to sites that promoted abuse and worse against trans and neurodivergent people.

https://www.vice.com/en/article/wxnxmb/cloudflare-wont-cut-off-kiwi-farms-stalking-forum

I haven't fully cut them out of my stack yet, they still handle the DNS routing for services running on my servers but I will get round to fixing this soon.

This entry was edited (1 year ago)
@Alastair Cooper friendica supports the abstract markup for CWs
I tried editing it, now it just seems to have hidden that line entirely but it might be my settings as I attempted to turn off CWs (for *me*, not other people seeing my content).